My first trip to the Lippeaue, the largest Taurus cattle breeding site in Germany and where the breed had its start, was in 2013. Now, two years later, I visited the reserve Naturreservat Lippeauen in Germany again to see how the herd developed within the the last two years.
At the moment I am preparing a large, extensive post on my trip and the animals with lots of pictures, but it will take its time until it is finished. So for now, a little teaser in form of a photo:
"Breeding-back" aims to restore or immitate extinct animals by selective breeding. This blog provides general information, the facts behind myths and news from various projects.
Monday, 26 October 2015
Saturday, 17 October 2015
Life illustration of the Indian aurochs
The whole
aurochs issue is centred almost entirely around the European subspecies, B. p. primigenius because it is the
best-documented subspecies and survived the longest. The Indian aurochs, the
wild ancestor of the zebu, was the first one to disappear and is very
enigmatic. There are only few skeletal remains (a number of crania, some
postcranial material), no artistic depictions have been claimed to show this
population nor are there written accounts. What we can infer from the
fossil-subfossil record is that namadicus
was smaller than primigenius (van Vuure 2005 mentions that some crania were
slightly smaller than those female Pleistocene primigenius). But
proportionally, its horns were larger and more wide-ranging (the only graphic
representation of namadicus material
I was able to find is that skull).
Therefore,
much of its appearance is unknown. In a post I did two years ago, I tried to
deduce some additional traits based on the scarce info we have and what seems credible
looking at living zebu and relatives. I consider the presence of a fleshy
zebuine hump unlikely for the wild-type (see the 2013 article). From all the
traits I hypothesized back then, here is a short summary plus some new thoughts
regarding colouration:
- proportions and body shape similar to primigenius, including a hump caused by high processus spinosi (no reason to think otherwise)
- a
posteriorly slightly down-turned pelvis
- The
dewlap might have been longer than in the European subspecies (although
probably not as extreme as in living zebu). Bovids in tropical climate often
have fleshy appendages for display and thermoregulation.
- Since all
un-mixed zebu breeds (as far as I know) have a typical E+//E+ colour, namadicus probably had a colour very
similar to the European aurochs: black or very dark bulls, much lighter
coloured bulls, muzzle ring in both sexes and a dorsal stripe at least in bulls. Many zebu have a diluted colour similar to podolian cattle, but there are some that have a colour not different from the European aurochs (see here). Zebus usually have the “zebu tipping gene” that causes a lightly coloured area
between the forelegs that may also extend to the belly and dewlap. This might
either be a mutation that happened right at the base of domestication, or it
was a trait possessed by namadicus
already. In my new reconstruction, I illustrate the latter option. The question
if the hair between the horns had a colour different from the rest of the head
is as unclear as it is in the European subspecies (it probably did not have the curlyforelocks of the European subspecies, since no zebu and no tropical bovine has
them). Some zebu show white rings around the eye, even males, as on this photo
by Markus Bühler. Perhaps this was the case in namadicus too, especially
because Banteng also show it. I consider it likely that cows would have it, but
perhaps not all bulls. Many aurochs-like-coloured zebu bulls have a saddle, and
this kind of saddle is different from that of taurine bulls: interestingly,
their saddle is not centred on the back of the trunk, but on the sides. This
might be a mutation as well, but for this illustration I speculated it is a
primitive state.
All in all
we get a more colourful aurochs for India. That is not unlikely, because bovids
of tropical climates are often rather colourful.
Before I
present my current reconstruction, I want to share some comments on my old one
(by the way; I have to admit that I am seemingly a kind of pioneer in
illustrating B.p. namadicus, I did my
first reconstruction in 2011 and I saw only one further illustration that might
be namadicus). The old one has some
anatomical flaws (position of the hump in the bull), and artistic ones (perspective
of the horns). I drew the waist a bit too slender for my taste now, and the
deep ribcage plus the high, straight hump makes it look too gaur-ish too me
today. Regarding the cow, I would still agree with it more or less nowadays,
but I will illustrate a female Indian aurochs another day. So for now, I drew
only a bull. Colour and stature were inspired by this miniature zebu bull.
It might surprise
that all its living descendants look so different. But I would say that is
because there are simply no truly primitive zebus left. Imagine all primitive
taurine breeds would vanish and the only breeds we would have left are such
like Angus, Holstein, Galloway and Belgian blue. I cannot say why there are no
primitive zebus left. It is possible that a genetic bottleneck was responsible,
or strong artificial selection or both.
As I
outlined in my 2013 post, a breeding-back project for B. primigenius namadicus could be done. But only a rather
minimalistic one, since we have no precise idea of the wild-type and all descendants
are rather derived. On the other hand, there
are zebus which have a rather aurochs-like colouration, such as those linked in this post, and there are breeds
like Some Gudzerat/Kankrej and other zebu that have proportions and horn
dimensions that are good and also useful horns (in our minimalist expectations).
Watussi have horn sizes that would help compensating the small horn sizes of
other zebu, and some of them also have a curvature that is not bad (being Sanga
cattle, they are mixed with taurine cattle; but the reverse also is often the
case so why not tolerating it). Looking at site for primitive, useful zebu in
India and south-east Asia might also show up some helpful results.
I think it
would be possible to breed a population of zebu that have the right colouration
and horn size, and a horn curve plus proportions that is tolerable. I might illustrate this idea too some day. They would
still show some of the “weird” zebu traits (overlong dewlap, large hanging
ears, fleshy hump). Nature would on a long-term sight further refine traits
such as body shape, neck- and shoulder muscles (zebu hump vs. spine-caused
hump), dewlap, horn orientation (there are no zebu with forwards-pointing horns
that I know of) and so on. Since we have no certain clue on colouration, a
certain amount of variation should be permitted (after all, even the grey
dilution factors could be a primitive state).
I am going
to illustrate the African subspecies, B.
p. africanus, soon.
Thursday, 15 October 2015
Tauros cattle arrived in CZ Republic
Today I was addressed to an article by derstandard.at by Margret Bunzel-Drüke from the ABU. It reports that a small starter herd of Tauros cattle have arrived in the CZ Republic. See here or here, for example. You see some photos of the herd on each of these links.
It has been prepared to set up a Tauros site in this country since at least 2010 if I remember correctly, now a herd of one bull and five cows accompanied by 15 Exmoor ponies have been released in the ex-military base Milovice on 40 hectares.
The background of these six animals is nebulous to me as usual. They are all rather young, so they might be second-generation crosses (at least some of them). I think that this cow, because of the shape and size of its horns, is likely to be half Highland x Maremmana, I have no idea what the father might be. The other long horned cow on the larger photo, might be Maremmana x Sayaguesa based on its looks, or of the same combination as the other one (because of the longer hair on its belly). The bull next to it looks as if it is the son of their Pajuna bull, it might also have a Highlander and/or Maremmana in its ancestry because of the large horns. Regarding the other animals, I have no clue. They could have anything from Sayaguesa, Pajuna, Tudanca, Limia and also Maronesa (in the case of the low-horned cow on this photo) in their ancestry.
All in all, based on what I have seen so far, the sexual dimorphism in the Tauros herds is weak so far. That is because the founding breeds are variable in this respect. In this variability, the Tauros animals tend to be on the "dark end" of the colour spectrum, as far as I can tell. It is not possible to tell what the horns will be like yet, because there is so much variability to be expected. I hope that the influence of Highland and Maremmana is enough to breed spectacular horn sizes. It is nice to see that many of the early cross products are slender and well-proportioned right from the beginning, what is not surprising since most of the founding breeds are of that type.
It has been prepared to set up a Tauros site in this country since at least 2010 if I remember correctly, now a herd of one bull and five cows accompanied by 15 Exmoor ponies have been released in the ex-military base Milovice on 40 hectares.
The background of these six animals is nebulous to me as usual. They are all rather young, so they might be second-generation crosses (at least some of them). I think that this cow, because of the shape and size of its horns, is likely to be half Highland x Maremmana, I have no idea what the father might be. The other long horned cow on the larger photo, might be Maremmana x Sayaguesa based on its looks, or of the same combination as the other one (because of the longer hair on its belly). The bull next to it looks as if it is the son of their Pajuna bull, it might also have a Highlander and/or Maremmana in its ancestry because of the large horns. Regarding the other animals, I have no clue. They could have anything from Sayaguesa, Pajuna, Tudanca, Limia and also Maronesa (in the case of the low-horned cow on this photo) in their ancestry.
All in all, based on what I have seen so far, the sexual dimorphism in the Tauros herds is weak so far. That is because the founding breeds are variable in this respect. In this variability, the Tauros animals tend to be on the "dark end" of the colour spectrum, as far as I can tell. It is not possible to tell what the horns will be like yet, because there is so much variability to be expected. I hope that the influence of Highland and Maremmana is enough to breed spectacular horn sizes. It is nice to see that many of the early cross products are slender and well-proportioned right from the beginning, what is not surprising since most of the founding breeds are of that type.
Wednesday, 7 October 2015
News from Lauresham
The first breeding site of the Uruz Project to be set up was Kloster Lorsch, Hessen, Germany. It is run by the Freilichtlabor Lauresham and the Förderkreis Große Pflanzenfresser im Kreis Bergstraße e.V., composed of a herd of very useful Chianina cows plus a young Watussi bull that had died in winter 14/15, delaying the project.
Recently both the groups mentioned plus Felix Hohmeyer (cooperating with them) quitted the cooperation with the True Nature Foundation and the Uruz Project. Therefore the herds at Lorsch and Bielefeld are not part of the UP anymore, therefore the Freilichtlabor and the Förderkreis Große Pflanzenfresser are doing breeding-back on their own now.
The herd at Lorsch currently consists of Chianina cows only, but they got a new young Watussi bull that is kept somewhere else until he is old enough (you might wonder why they don't by an adult one in the first place, the reason is that there was none available). The herd at Bielefeld currently consists, as planned, of a number of Watussi cows from Brüggen (NRW), plus the young Chianina bull "Bruno", a son of the cows from Lorsch.
They are pretty sure the bull covered the cow already, so that we can finally expect a first-generation cross animal for 2016. At first glimpse looks "small", but keep in mind that he is only 1 1/5 years old and therefore he is quite large for his age. Furthermore, he is the son of the largest cow at Lorsch (165cm), therefore Claus Kropp is confident that he will get really tall.
A new herd in Einhausen is planned to be set up for this year. They want to keep with the original idea of creating to breed lines consisting of Chianina x Watussi plus Sayaguesa x Hungarian Grey/Maremmana. I don't know which one the new herd is going to be part of.
They have created a breeding book plus a photo gallery to document the identity of the animals. It is not sure whether the photo gallery and breeding book will become online or not.
This is a thing the Tauros Project missed, leading to a situation where the responsible people sometimes don't know the identity of some of their animals themselves, as far as we "outsiders" know.
Recently both the groups mentioned plus Felix Hohmeyer (cooperating with them) quitted the cooperation with the True Nature Foundation and the Uruz Project. Therefore the herds at Lorsch and Bielefeld are not part of the UP anymore, therefore the Freilichtlabor and the Förderkreis Große Pflanzenfresser are doing breeding-back on their own now.
The herd at Lorsch currently consists of Chianina cows only, but they got a new young Watussi bull that is kept somewhere else until he is old enough (you might wonder why they don't by an adult one in the first place, the reason is that there was none available). The herd at Bielefeld currently consists, as planned, of a number of Watussi cows from Brüggen (NRW), plus the young Chianina bull "Bruno", a son of the cows from Lorsch.
Young Chianina bull plus a Watussi cow at Bielefeld. Kindly provided by Claus Kropp. |
A new herd in Einhausen is planned to be set up for this year. They want to keep with the original idea of creating to breed lines consisting of Chianina x Watussi plus Sayaguesa x Hungarian Grey/Maremmana. I don't know which one the new herd is going to be part of.
They have created a breeding book plus a photo gallery to document the identity of the animals. It is not sure whether the photo gallery and breeding book will become online or not.
This is a thing the Tauros Project missed, leading to a situation where the responsible people sometimes don't know the identity of some of their animals themselves, as far as we "outsiders" know.