Saturday, 20 February 2021

European wild horse colour phenotypes

Back in 2013, I did an illustration of the five colour phenotypes found in European wild horses according to genetic research and presented it in a post (back in the time when I called the European wild horse "tarpan", which I nowadays do not). I also put it on Wikipedia, but it was removed by some know-it-alls editing the German page. 
I recently did an updated version of that illustration. Back in 2013 I considered it likely that the European wild horse had a falling mane, which I no longer do (see here). I corrected it, and here is the result: 
It shows all the colour phenotypes confirmed for Equus ferus ferus so far, including: bay dun (top left), bay + nondun1 (top right), black dun (middle left), black + nondun1 (middle right), leopard spotted (bottom). For the references for the colour phenotypes see [1,2]. Black and black dun are caused by the allele a, which became the dominant allele later in the Holocene (whether the phenotype is black or black dun depends on the alleles on the Dun locus) [3], while Pleistocene horses all had the A+ allele, and thus were either bay or bay dun. A 2015 study [4] examined the alleles on the dun locus in a late Pleistocene (42.700 years old) wild horse from Russia and that of a 4000 years old horse (also from Russia). It turned out that the Pleistocene wild horse was heterozygous for dun and nondun1, thus had a dun phenotype. And since all wild horses from that time were A+//A+, it must have been bay dun and thus looked like the drawing at the top left. The 4000 years old horse (whether it was a wild horse or domestic horse was not tested), was homozygous for nondun1. Thus, if it was a wild horse, it looked like the illustration at the top right, since the a allele was not found in Russian samples. 

I also gave the leopard spotted wild horse a dark neck and face, matching the cave art (see here). 

Literature 

[1] Pruvost et al.: Genotypes of predomestic horses match phenotypes painted in paleolithic works of cave art. 2011
 [2] Ludwig et al.: Coat color variation at the beginning of horse domestication2009.
[3] Sandoval-Castellanos et al.: Coat colour adaption of post-glacial horses to increasing forest vegetation. 2017
[4] Imsland et al.: Regulatory mutations in TBX3disrupt asymmetric hair pigmentation that underlies Dun camouflage colour in horses. 2015.


8 comments:

  1. In some of the cave paintings there is a marked difference between the light belly and the brown on the rest of the body. After looking at photos of przewalski's horses, I consider that to be a winter trait. Would you agree?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Also, in Ekain there are both bay duns and black duns with very distinct primitive markings and to my surprise some horses with a white rump. I suppose there were different subspecies.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Roman Paintings just restored in Pompei . A wild bull attacjed by a lion
    https://www.artribune.com/arti-visive/archeologia-arte-antica/2021/02/pompei-restauro-casa-dei-ceii/

    ReplyDelete
  4. Roan:
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roan_(horse)
    http://tigercanyon.com/game/

    ReplyDelete
  5. Do you have any links which point to the genetic research of A+? As far as I could find only A has been located, but not A+ or At.
    And if the A+ gene is not known, then how is it determined that A+ is the predomesticated bay type, and not A or At?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You are right, that's a mistake of mine. Only A has been found in wild horses, not A+. But as far as I know, the genetic test can only detect the presence of a, and therefore not discriminate between A, A+ or At. So the wild horses found not to have a could have any of these three alleles as far as I understand.

      Delete
  6. Dear Mr. Foidl,

    I am currently working on a research article for the Dutch paleontological magazine Cranium. The subject of my article is how cave paintings can be used in the reconstruction of prehistoric mammals, and horses are one of the creatures featured in the article.

    I'd like to request the usage of a watermarkless version of the image on this blogpost. The previous version can be found on Wikimedia Commons, but I'd like to use the updated version if possible. If you agree with this, you will of course be credited accordingly within the article itself and I shall send you a free PDF-copy of the final product as well.

    If you'd like to discuss this, please send a message to my e-mail account, julian.doop@live.nl.

    I hope to hear from you.

    Kind regards,

    Julian Doop

    ReplyDelete
  7. In several Cantabrian caves, including La Pena de Candamo and Tito Bustillo, there are horses represented with a purple coloration. It seems like this might have been attempting to represent a bay or black dun coloration, which especially when lightened from the sun could look reddish-purple. The manes of all the purple horses are deliberately outlined in black, so it seems like they were probably not black non-dun horses, since those would be all the same color.

    ReplyDelete