I have been
running this blog since 2013 now, which is 13 years. After exactly one and a
half decades of collecting info on the aurochs and wild horses (I started
getting into this topic in 2011), my
conceptions of what I consider the most likely scenario based on the available
evidence on a number of topics shifted. With this post, I want to give an
overview over where my opinions or assumptions changed in the last 13 years,
especially as some very old blog posts show outdated assumptions of mine. I try
to put disclaimers on every blogpost that I consider outdated and link to an
up-to-date article, but with my 550+ blogposts, it takes a while. So, here is a
comprehensive list:
-
The
neck muscles in aurochs bulls
Taurine
domestic bulls all can have two kinds of neck musculature: either a so-called
“crest”, where the neck forms a bulge that is separate from the shoulder hump
(if present) or a neck that is still very muscular but with a smoother
transition to the shoulder hump. Prime examples for these different bull necks
are Lidia and Sayaguesa. The former has the first described neck shape, the
latter one the latter. The length of the dorsal spine seems to play no role in
this, it seems to depend on the development of the musculature. This begs the
question: what kind of neck shape did the aurochs have?
Looking at
extant wild bovines, we see both kinds of necks, but dependent on the species.
Gaur have a neck crest, Banteng have a less developed neck musculature. Wisent
have a neck crest, while American bison have the neck merging with the shoulder
hump. So phylogenetic bracketing is not useful to resolve this question. So I
reasoned until a few years ago that the hormonal changes from aurochs to domestic
meant that aurochs had more testosterone, and the M. trapezius is particularly testosterone-dependent
(partly). So I figured that the neck crest is more likely for the aurochs. I no
longer uphold this reasoning. First of all, there is no direct evidence that
aurochs bulls had higher testosterone than domestic bulls, however likely it
may be. Also, the testosterone level is not the only factor influencing the
amount of the muscle tissue, it is also the number of androgen receptors to
which the testosterone binds that plays a role. Hence an aurochs bull could
have had a much higher testosterone level than a domestic bull with a crest and
still have no crest. So this reasoning was not suitable to determine if aurochs
bulls had a “Lidia neck” or “Sayaguesa neck”.
Also, cave
paintings and other contemporaneous artistic depictions of aurochs bulls are
unambiguous in this respect: they all, and I mean all, show a “Sayaguesa neck”.
Hence, I was wrong on the assumption that aurochs bulls must have had a neck
crest.
-
The
mane of European wild horses
I no longer
believe that European wild horses had a falling mane like domestic horses. I
used to think that because of the claim that the Equus caballus lambei
carcass has a falling mane, but that one has never been properly described. And
even if it had a falling mane, it would not be possible to implicate a falling
mane in European wild horses by phylogenetic bracketing, as lambei is
more distantly related to those than is the Przewalski’s horse. Also, a Equus
caballus lenensis horse carcass has a very short mane of only 15cm, which
was probably standing. Furthermore, Iberian wild horses are even more distantly
related to domestic horses than Przewalski’s, therefore their mane was very
likely standing. And, not to forget, all cave paintings show horses with an
upright mane. Domestication also caused a hanging mane in some donkey breeds,
so we can be rather sure to assume that the falling mane is an artefact of
domestication in horses too and that European wild horses had a standing mane.
-
Hybridization
with wild bovines in “breeding-back”
When I
started the blog, I was opposed to the idea of hybridization with existing wild
bovines for “breeding-back”. I thought that this would introduce many undesired
traits not only to morphology, which is the lesser problem because it is easily
“visible”, but also concerning behaviour and ecology, which are rather tricky
to select against. However, nowadays I think that if the doses are small enough
and if the hybridization is carried out with a meticulous selection scheme, introducing
suitable species can be very beneficial to “breeding-back”, and if done in an
experimental population with its own herd book, there is no way this can do
harm. The species I am considering are (Java) banteng, wild yak and nowadays
also wisent.
-
Certainty
with which we know the aurochs’ life appearance
I used to
think that the life appearance of the aurochs is well-resolved. We have living
descendants and close relatives for extant phylogenetic bracketing, we have
historical texts describing the animal that match with ancient art. However,
nowadays I think it is not that easy. For example, if domestic cattle display a
certain peculiar trait that is not found in wild bovines, it cannot easily be
assumed it is an artefact of domestication. An example would be the somewhat
sloping backs of many domestic cattle. Wild bovines tend not to have that
(except in certain positions when they stretch their hindlimbs, so that the
back is sloping), and some domestics have it pronounced extremely. I saw no
functional benefit to this trait and thus I assumed that aurochs had a strictly
horizontal lumbar spine, as do extant wild bovines. However, almost all ancient
art shows aurochs with sloping backs. The skeletons do not help us in
determining which posture is that of the aurochs, since this would mainly
depend on the length of the ligaments and muscles in questions. Thus, we don’t
know but I am inclined to think they had a somewhat sloping back. But we cannot
be sure. Another point is blond or red hair between the horns; many
wildtype-coloured bulls have them, historic texts never describe them and one
belt made of the skin between the horns of an aurochs with the fur still
attached was black. However, this is not a large sample size at all. And we do
not have that much historic texts speaking of the forelocks, actually only
three (Schneeberger, von Herberstein and Swiecicky). This can barely account
for a possible variation spectrum, if there was one. We don’t know. The same
goes for a lightly-coloured saddle in European bulls. Evidence only points
against such a trait in males, but I recently reported that there is one cave
painting that might be interpreted showing a bull with a light trunk. These are
just examples; although the life appearance and morphology of the aurochs is
comparably well-resolved, it is not completely resolved. I’d say somewhere
between 80 and 90%.
-
Bulkiness
of the aurochs
This could
actually be included in the upper point but I mention it separately because
this does not necessarily only depend on species-specific aspects. The bulk of
a bovine depends a lot on how well it is fed and therefore also the seasons
(this is even mentioned in Schneeberger’s text on the aurochs), but also the
age – bulls in particular, even in wild bovines, can grow extremely hefty with
age. I often used young Lidia bulls as orientation for my bull reconstructions,
mostly because I always feared making my aurochs too bulky would make them look
“domestic”. But Lidia bulls are, when allowed to get fully developed, actually
very massive. Von Herberstein’s illustration of his stuffed specimen shows a
very massive animal that looks basically like a sausage. And this is compatible
with a number of cave paintings and engravings, such as the one from Grotta del
Romito or Dordogne. So I underestimated the bulk of fully grown aurochs bulls
in the past, mainly because I did not want to fall in the pitfall of many
artists reconstructing the aurochs of making it look like a domestic bull with
aurochs horns and colour. So I fell in another pitfall.
-
My
aurochs reconstructions
Nowadays I
think some of my earlier reconstructions of the aurochs are inaccurate in some
respects, mainly because I exaggerated the morphology unintentionally when I
tried to appreciate the fact that it was a wild bovine and not a domestic one. I
am still trying to figure out some anatomical details, it is a learning process
and also open to a lot of interpretation.
-
The
reliability of cave paintings
I never
dismissed cave paintings as a source completely, especially for colour. But for
morphological aspects, I considered them to be too stylized or imprecise to be
used as a strict guideline. This may still be correct as a whole but I think if
all cave paintings, in their imprecision and stylization, show a certain
anatomical trait independently, it should be taken seriously. For example, it
seems the dewlap of the aurochs was shaped differently from that of domestic
cattle and more similar to that of banteng and steers. Also, only few cave
paintings support the super-athletic morphology of my reconstructions that were
based on young Lidia bulls, they all, or many, show rather bulky animals. Also,
many of them show rather longish bulls, which makes me wonder how much the
intervertebral discs of the spine added to the trunk length of the skeleton in
the living animal, which ties to the point of uncertainty about the morphology
of the animal.
-
Zebu
hump in the Indian aurochs
I was
completely unsure on whether a zebu hump was already present in Indian aurochs
or not, tending to reject the idea based on the literature I found that claim
no function for the hump has been determined yet. It seems though, as several
breeders of indicine breeds have told me, that the fat deposit that surrounds
the hypertrophied M. rhomboideus that forms the hump gets much fatter during
summer and decreases almost to nil during winter. This is actually a common
strategy in ruminants to deal with the seasons: to acquire a surplus during
summer when food is abundant and living on the fat storage during winter.
That’s why free-ranging cattle often look very skinny during winter but
“recover” just fine. Now, India does not have winter in the sense of snowfall,
but its vegetation is heavily monsoon-dependent and goes through a severe dry
phase every year. And concentrating the fat storage in one spot instead of
dispersing it around the whole body would actually be efficient in a hot
climate from a thermoregulatory aspect. So it might indeed be possible that the
Indian aurochs did have a zebu hump and that it had a function.
 |
| New little sculpture I made of Bos taurus namadicus with a hump, based on the GIS skull. |
-
Usage
of the name “tarpan” and Equus ferus
There is so
much confusion around the word “tarpan”. It started as a local, colloquial name
for local free-ranging horses which may or may not have been wild or at least
partly wild horses. Then it got transferred, after the extinction of these
populations, by some authors onto what they considered wild horses of Europe.
This got adopted by many later authors of the 20th century,
reframing the usage of a local term for horses of dubious nature in the southwestern
Eurasian steppe in the 19th century to a synonym of the original
western Eurasian wild horses, creating the false impression that it was the
colloquial name for this animal in Europe, which never was unambiguously the
case. There is a chance that the horses historically called tarpan were wild
horses with only minor admixture from escaped domestic horses, but we cannot
verify this. Therefore, using this local historical term for the biological
wild horse of Western Eurasia is not wise.
Very, very widespread
is the use of Equus ferus for the species of the wild horse. This is actually
ill-grounded, even if you consider wildtypes species distinct from their
domestic descendants. Equus ferus does not have a type specimen, not even a
lectotype. It is loosely based on a written description of free-ranging horses
encountered by Gmelin in the 18th century. Gmelin spotted a
free-ranging herd of horses consisting of what he considered wild horses, a
mare he recognized as domestic plus her hybrid foal. I see no compelling reason
to regard Equus ferus as suitable for qualifying as the binominal name for the
wild horse, not at all. I think the adoption of this name for the species of
wild horse was a poor decision by later authors. In fact, the first binominal
name that was unambiguously based on a wild horse with a type specimen is Equus
przewalskii. Therefore, if you regard wild horses as a species distinct
from their domestic descendants, you would have to refer to them as Equus przewalskii,
not Equus ferus. If you consider wild and domestic horses one species, this
species would unambiguously have to be referred to as Equus caballus.
-
The
purity of the last wild horses in Europe
This will
remain a matter of debate forever, as historic texts are not definite enough to
be sure about the nature of the last remaining free-ranging horses western to
the Ural river. However, genetic evidence points to at least some of them being
partly a distinct ancient wild horse strain, and there is even the chance that
the very last “tarpan” kept at the Moscow zoo was “pure” or hat only minor
domestic influence. I go over this in great detail in my book available on
amazon.
-
Usage
of Bos primigenius
I used to
prefer Bos primigenius over Bos taurus for the species of aurochs
and cattle because the former has a holotype and the latter does not. However,
following the rules of the ICZN very strictly actually Bos taurus has priority
over Bos primigenius because opinion 2027 does not apply: Linnaeus described
both the aurochs and cattle under Bos taurus in 1758, he explicitly mentions
the “ferus Urus Poloniae”. Thus, Bos taurus is not a senior
synonym of the aurochs based on its domestic counterpart, in which case opinion
2027 would apply, it is the aurochs and always was. This was just
overlooked by later authors, possibly because many considered the “urus”
to be identical to the wisent until Bojanus 1827.
My instagram page
A lot of my new paleoart and reconstructions will be uploaded to my instagram profile. Check it out if you want to see my newest art and aurochs reconstructions.