"Breeding-back" aims to restore or immitate extinct animals by selective breeding. This blog provides general information, the facts behind myths and news from various projects. instagram: @daniel.foidl
Thursday, 27 June 2024
What is your favourite "breeding-back" project/breed/lineage/herd?
Sunday, 16 June 2024
I have a Facebook page now
I did not post much here recently (mostly because I am busy finishing my book on "breeding-back"), but I have a lot of posts in preparation. Meanwhile, you can take a look at my new facebook page "Daniel Foidl Paleoart and Breeding-back". I post most of my recent (and also older) artworks there, mostly dinosaur-related but I will also upload aurochs-related artworks and maybe also other content to the page. I'm looking forward to see you there, thanks!
Thursday, 19 January 2023
Extinct megafauna that could be revived using genome editing
Humans wiped out countless species of animals. Some of those species, particularly those that died out comparably recently, might actually be retrievable. Usually, cloning comes to mind when talking about reviving extinct animals. However, somatic nucleus transfer for reproductive cloning requires an intact cell and not just the DNA of the animal, which is why it is not available for most species wiped out by man. However, there are a few megafaunal species that have been wiped off from which we have at least one and in some cases several complete genomes. If there is a still extant species that is closely related and would make a suitable surrogate, it would be possible to exchange the alleles specific for species A with those for species B and thus creating a viable cell with the genome of the extinct species in question with genome editing. This limits the number of extinct animals that could be revived. For example, I would imagine it to be pretty difficult if not impossible for a species like the thylacine, which has been evolutionary separated for 30 million years from its closest living relatives. In some cases, it could be easy and much less effortful because of the lower number of genes that differ and the suitability of the surrogate because the animal has a very close living relative. In this post, I present a number of megafaunal species from which full genomes either have been acquired or at least could potentially be acquired and which have a more or less closely related relative that can be used for genome editing and as a surrogate. The mitochondrial DNA of the resulting animal would be that of the donor cell, which would be from the related species. However, as mitochondrial genes are highly conserved among mammals this would not have much of an influence. Using closely related species also has the advantage that the behaviour will be rather similar, especially among the large herbivore species that I am going to list. This makes the rearing by a surrogate mother and socialization of the result less problematic or maybe not even an issue at all.
I see reviving an extinct animal that has been wiped out by man as a contribution to species conservation just as breeding an endangered species or subspecies. One might ask, particularly in the case of wiped-out subspecies, why doing that at all if there are suitable ecological proxies. Occasionally some even question the need to conserve endangered subspecies such as the Northern White rhino because their conspecifics from other subspecies would function ecologically the same or very similar. Personally, I cannot relate to that mindset. Conservation is about preserving biodiversity and the preservation of evolutionary more or less distinct subspecies is a vital part of that. The same goes for reviving extinct species or subspecies – it would greatly increase the biodiversity again, after it has been depleted by man when the species or subspecies was wiped out.
Bubal hartebeest, Alcelaphus buselaphus
This animal is sometimes also considered a subspecies, but that question is merely taxonomical and not relevant for “de-extincting” the animal. In any case, other members of Alcelaphus could be used for genome editing and as a surrogate. Many individuals must have been preserved as trophies, and it is potentially possible to acquire full nuclear genomes from them.
Bluebuck, Hippotragus leucophaeus
Other members of Hippotragus could be used as a surrogate and for genome editing. It can be tried to acquire a fully nuclear genome from taxidermies.
European aurochs, Bos primigenius primigenius
One full nuclear genome has been resolved in 2015 from a well-preserved Neolithic bone. Considering the richness of recent aurochs material, it could be possible to obtain quite a few more complete genomes. And there is a very close living relative, modern cattle. The number of genes that would have to be exchanged would probably be lower than in most of the other cases I am listing here, and also the surrogate and the procedure of implanting an embryo would be completely unproblematic. And considering the similarities in behaviour between cattle and aurochs, socialization will not be problematic either. For these reasons, I consider the aurochs one of the most realistic candidates for a revival through genome editing. Even if the resolved genome remains the only one to be fully resolved, one revived aurochs individual still can be outbred using aurochs-like cattle. I wrote a post on that a few years ago.
Several types of wild horses
There are well-preserved mummies of Siberian wild horses, Equus caballus lenensis, and one of the Yukon wild horse, Equus caballus lambei, so it could be possible to obtain fully resolved nuclear genomes from that. A domestic horse could be used for genome editing and as a surrogate. Even if only one genome can be obtained, the revived horses can be outbred with Przewalski’s horses and/or robust landraces in the same manner as I suggested for revived aurochs.
Kouprey, Bos sauveli
Numerous kouprey specimen have been preserved as trophies and one skin. It could be possible to obtain full nuclear genomes from that very recent material. The closest living relative is the Cambodian banteng which hybridized with the kouprey in the past. It can be used for genome editing, as a surrogate and even for outbreeding if necessary.
Quagga, Equus quagga quagga
The quagga is not and cannot be bred-back from extinction with living Plains zebras, which is why it would be desirable to try to acquire full genomes from the numerous preserved skins and the few skeletal material that is preserved of this zebra. The zebras of the Quagga Project can be used for genome editing, as a surrogate and outbreeding if necessary.
Pyrenean ibex, Capra pyrenaica pyrenaica
This is the only extinct animal that has been cloned so far, unfortunately the clone died shortly after birth. Genome editing with individuals from other subspecies of Capra pyrenaica could be more successful, they can be used as surrogates and for outbreeding.
Steppe bison, Bos (Bison) priscus
There are plentiful of remains from steppe bison, including soft tissue. Perhaps it would be possible to obtain full nuclear genomes from that. Needless to say, that still existing bison, be it European or American, can be used for genome editing, as a surrogate and outbreeding.
? Woolly mammoth, Mammuthus primigenius
Currently, there is no de-extinction project in the strict sense focusing on the woolly mammoth. There is the attempt to create a “mammophant” by introducing mammoth alleles for certain traits into the genome of an Asian elephant, what is not what I would consider de-extinction in the strict sense. If doing that is possible, it might also be possible even if more effortful, to exchange all alleles of genes where Asian elephant and woolly mammoth differ. However, since implanting an embryo into an elephant is very complicated, and those who want to create plan to use an artificial womb, a technique which does not exist hitherto, I wonder if it is feasible to recreate the woolly mammoth for practical reasons.
Caucasian Wisent, Bos (Bison) bonasus caucasicus
Several skins and trophies of this wiped-out subspecies (or species or variety, there is no consensus on its taxonomic status) exist, so it could be possible to obtain full nuclear genomes from it. European bison of the Lowland-Caucasus line, which partly descend from the last Caucasian wisent bull, could be used for genome editing, as a surrogate and for outbreeding. Obtaining genomes from remains of wisent prior to the bottleneck in the 20th century could also help to greatly increase the very limited genetic diversity of this endangered bovine.
Cave lion, Panthera spelaea
Several very well-preserved pubs of this feline have been found. It might be possible to acquire full nuclear genomes from that, and the closely related actual lion would be suitable for genome editing and as a surrogate.
Schomburgk’s deer, Rucervus schomburgki
Some remains of this deer species exist, a sister species from the Rucervus clade could be used for genome editing and as a surrogate.
Japanese sea lion, Zalophus japonicus
There are taxidermied specimens of this sea lion, related species of the Zalophus clade can be used for genome editing, as a surrogate and possibly outbreeding if necessary.
Caribbean monk seal, Neomonachus tropicalis
There should be some remains of this recently extinct species, the related Hawaiian monk seal can be used for genome editing, as a surrogate and possibly outbreeding if necessary.
One common objection against the revival of extinct animals is “one individual is not enough to build a population”. Apart from the fact that even one individual could tell us a lot about the extinct animal species/subspecies, it could be possible to get several genomes of those recently extinct species. Getting the full genome of five or ten individuals from different regions and times would probably enable to get a genetic diversity comparable to that of the modern wisent population, which descends from only twelve founding individuals from the same population. Some wisent individuals show inbreeding-related problems, but not to the extent that it threatens the survival of the species. An even more extreme example would be the Mauritius kestrel. Apart from that, related species/subspecies can always be used for outbreeding to add genetic diversity. Hybridization among related species with neighboring or overlapping distributions is very common in the animal kingdom.
Tuesday, 3 January 2023
The dingo: a post-domestic wild animal?
Long-term readers of my blog will be familiar with my dedomestication hypothesis that I proposed in the dedomestication series. The term dedomestication is not very established in scientific literature yet, but there can be now doubt that natural selection will change domestic animals that have returned into the wild. This evolutionary process would result in what I call a post-domestic wildtype, opposed to a predomestic wildtype. This post-domestic wildtype would be just as wild as any other wild animal, with the difference that it descends from a domestic population.
I proposed that this post-domestic wildtype is not necessarily a revert to the original predomestic wildtype, but that it depends on the selective pressures in the respective environment, genetic drift and also that novel traits can be beneficial, especially in a new environment. As I write in my dedomestication series, the hypothesis has empirical problems. For once, feral domestic animals are understudied in terms of possible evolutionary changes they experience. And moreover, there are hardly any feral domestic populations that have been living in the wild under natural selection for a considerable time span sufficient for evolutionary changes to become visible and at the same time reproductively isolated from backcrossing with wild or domestic animals. For example, feral pigs in North America (razorbacks) sometimes greatly resemble the Eurasian wild boar, what would endorse one of the main proposals of the dedomestication hypothesis (namely that wildtype traits tend to have a higher evolutionary fitness and thus the feral population starts to resemble the original wildtype on adaptive traits). The problem is, however, that these feral pigs often hybridized with wild boar that have been introduced there as well, what explains the resemblance between the two.
Nevertheless, I see two possible candidates for a post-domestic wildtype because of a considerable time span they have been reproductively isolated and exposed to natural selection: the dingo and the European mufflon. This post is going to focus on the dingo. But first of all, it is essential to define which criteria an animal would have to fit if it was to be considered a post-domestic wildtype.
A definition of the post-domestic wildtype
The most abstract definition of a post-domestic wild animal would be that its biology is entirely shaped by natural selection and not artificial selection. In detail, this would mean:
- It is devoid of typical signs of domestication: paedomorphy in behaviour and morphology, earlier maturity, loss of seasonal adaptions, white spotted patterns in the colour or other detrimental colour mutations, reduced brain volume, reduced sexual dimorphism
- It is adapted to the biotic and abiotic factors of its environment
- It is more or less homogeneous in its biology, especially regarding adaptive characters
The exact time span of how long the animal has been subject to natural selection is technically of limited relevance, because the speed at which evolutionary changes become evident depends on how genetically diverse the starting gene pool is – this is known as Fisher’s fundamental theorem and it describes that changes in allele frequency occur faster in a very diverse population compared to one that is genetically homogeneous.
Is the dingo a dog at all and does it have domestic ancestry?
A question which has to be investigated before is if it is true at all that the dingo has a domestic ancestry and if it is a dog at all. That question is relevant as there are some sources questioning the status of the dingo as a dog and prefer to regard it as a separate wild canid species that was never domesticated like coyotes and golden jackals.
This idea, however, seems to be contradicted by the genetic evidence. Jackson et al. 2019 have reviewed several phylogenies based on genetic analyses and all of them have the dingo placed within the phylogenetic tree of the dog [1]. This strongly implies that the ancestors of the dingo were domestic dogs. One recent study from 2022 had the dingo as a sister group to all other dog breeds examined, but the number of dog breeds used was only six [2], therefore very low considering that there are hundreds of dog breeds. It was found that the dingo has only one copy of the AMY2B gene, which is multiplied in other dog breeds as an adaption to starch-rich diet [2]. That is, however, not an argument in favour of the idea that the dingo is a never domesticated wild canid, it just means that the duplication of the gene did not occur right at the beginning of dog domestication so that there are breeds that do not have it. That would be like claiming Sayaguesa cannot be domestic because it has the E+ allele, which is wildtype. The dog breeds that group with the dingo are, among others, the Chow Chow, the Akita, the Basenji and Indonesian and various Southeast Asian dogs [1,3]. Half of the dingoes tested in one study have the A29 mitochondrial haplotype (which is considered ancestral to all the other mitochondrial dingo haplotypes), which is also found in East Asian, Southeast Asian and American dogs as well as the New Guinea singing dog [4]. So from a genetic perspective, there can be no question that the dingo is a dog and shares domestic ancestors with other dogs.
It is also morphological evidence that contradicts the idea that the dingo is a distinct, never domesticated wild canid species. Dingoes do have vestiges of domestication, including typically domestic traits such as a brain volume reduced by 30% compared to the grey wolf [5], reduced mimics and less social differentiation compared to the grey wolf [5,6], curly tails in some individuals [7] and cranial paedomorphy [8] and the males are able to reproduce all the year round [7]. Moreover, some dingoes have clearly domestic coat colour variants, such as brindle or white-spotted or piebald patterns. All these traits strongly suggest that the dingo is a dog, sharing domestic ancestors with other dog breeds.
Also the behaviour of the dingo demonstrates that it is a dog – dingoes are sometimes kept as pet dogs, and already the Australian aboriginal people kept dingoes [9]. Alfred Brehm in Brehm’s Tierleben reported that there were dingoes kept as pet dogs and were used to protect livestock. Also, ethologist Eberhart Trumler studied dingoes kept as pet dogs and reported that they can even be made house-trained. Keeping a wild canine, be it a wolf, a coyote or jackal, as a pet dog this way would be impossible.
Therefore, putting everything together, I think there is no reason to not assume that the dingo is a dog and shares domestic ancestors with other dog breeds.
Does the dingo fit the definition of post-domestic? Is it wild or feral?
My definition of post-domestic can be seen above, it has three key points. Without question the dingo is adapted to its Australian environment, it can make use of various food sources and it is adapted to the climate as the wide geographic range on the continent demonstrates. Concerning its morphology, the dingo seems to be uniform like a wild animal. Concerning its colours, they are more variable than what is commonly expected. A 2021 study found that because of the variation in the dingo’s coat colour, this parameter cannot be used to discern pure dingoes from hybrids with other, later arrived feral dogs [10]. Wild animals are usually – usually, not always – comparably uniform in colour across the species and the dingo coat colour variation is obviously a vestige of domestication. However, if the domestic coat colour variants found in the dingo (I consider all of the colours found in the dingo domestic, i.e. they arose after domestication, as none of them are the wildtype colours shared by wolves, the ancestors of dogs) turn out to be adaptive in the new environment they have been introduced to (Australia), they cannot be used as an argument against a possible wild status. If a novel trait that arose during domestication is adaptive in a new environment and becomes fixed, it would actually be in line with my dedomestication hypothesis. I never proposed that a feral domestic animal would fully revert to the original wildtype under natural selection, because some novel traits can be adaptive especially when the population lives in a new environment that is different from that of the original wildtype. In Australia, the colour of the dingo is likely better camouflage than that of the wolf in Asia where the dog was domesticated. Therefore, the colour of the dingo is likely adaptive. Perhaps some more millennia of dedomestication will eventually lead to a uniform colour, via stabilizing selection and genetic drift. Therefore, if a possible post-domestic animal has retained novel traits that arose during domestication, it still can fit the criteria for being a post-domestic wild animal as long as these novel traits are either adaptive or evolutionary neutral. But the dingo also has other remnant traits of its domestic ancestry as outlined above, some of which are part of the universal “domestication syndrome” and possibly maladaptive, including the reduced brain volume, cranial paedomorphy and curly tails in some individuals. Also, the fact that dingo males are able to reproduce all year round shows that they have not yet fully redeveloped a seasonal reproduction circle. Moreover, the fact that dingoes can be used and trained as pet dogs shows that the neurologic-endocrinologic modifications that turned dogs into domestic animals are still present in the dingo, and that it has not yet lost the potential to develop domestic behaviour. To me, this suggests that the dingo should not be considered a post-domestic wild animal.
It is problematic, however, to draw a distinctive line between feral and post-domestic wild. Rather it should be regarded as a continuum, as a spectrum. The dingo definitely is on this spectrum, but in my opinion still closer to feral than to post-domestic wild. Interestingly, there also seems to be a continuum from other basal dogs to the dingo, as Southeast Asian pariah dogs, Borneo dogs, the Korean Jindu and the American Carolina dog are phenotypically very similar to dingoes. All of them, including the dingo, can be kept as pets.
An upcoming post is going to focus on the European mufflon as a post-domestic wild animal candidate.
Literature
[1] Jackson et al.: The Dogma of Dingoes – Taxonomic status of the dingo: A reply to Smith et al.. 2019.
[2] Field et al.: The Australian dingo is an early offshoot of modern breed dogs. 2022.
[3] Larson et al.: Rethinking dog domestication by integrating genetics, archeology, and biogeography. 2012.
[4] Savolainen et al.: A detailed picture of the origin of the Australian dingo, obtained from the study of mitochondrial DNA. 2004.
[5] Hemmer: Domestikation, Verarmung der Merkwelt. 1983
[6] Trumler: Ein Hund wird geboren: der Ratgeber für den Hundefreund. 1982.
[7] Zimen: Der Hund – Abstammung – Verhalten – Mensch und Hund. 1988.
[8] Smith et al.: Brain size/body weight in the dingo (Canis dingo): comparisons with domestic and wild canids. 2017.
[9] Roland Breckwoldt: The dingo: still a very elegant animal. In: A symposium on the dingo. 2001.
[10] Cairns et al.: Pelage variation in dingoes across southeastern Australia: implications for conservation and management. 2021.
Saturday, 14 March 2020
Some questions and answers
Monday, 21 October 2019
Controlled hybridization for saving the wisent?
See here for a comparison between wood bison (left) and plains bison (right). As you see, the wood bison also morphologically resembles the wisent better than the plains bison.
