"Breeding-back" aims to restore or immitate extinct animals by selective breeding. This blog provides general information, the facts behind myths and news from various projects.
Thursday, 19 November 2015
A second trip to the Lippeaue Pt.II: The Herds #1
The Lippeaue herds counted 101 animals when I visited the herd.
There are five herds: Klostermersch-Südseite (25 animals, 6 being calves),
Klostermersch-Nordseite (22 animals, 7 being calves), Hellinghauser Mersch (38
animals, 14 being calves), Disselmersch (7 animals), Kleiberg (7 animals, 1
being a calf). This post covers Kleiberg, Klostermersch-Nord and Disselmersch. Klostermersch-Süd and Hellinghauser Mersch are going to be featured in a second one. (I claim copyright for my photos, please do not use without permission)
Kleiberg
This site
was created only two years ago in 2013, with a starter herd numbering 3
individuals. Now there are several adult and subadult animals. The breeding
bull is Linnet, son of their now dead Sayaguesa bull Churro and a cow that I simply
classify as a “mix” (without Lidia). Linnet made a good impression on me when I
first saw him on a video, but now he looks short-legged, so it is not sure how
long he will be kept as a breeding bull. He has a colour saddle, which I am not
a fan of, and also a bit paedomorphic face. The horns have a nice curvature
(see the photo), but in an aurochs they would probably protrude several inches
longer (nevertheless nice, thick horns). The oldest individual is the cow
Ludovica, one of the “oldies” (Heck x Chianina). She is the stabilizing element
in the herd in the social sense. Together with Linnet she gave rise to a
beautiful young bull (01 851). For now, 01 851 has good proportions, but the
question always is how much that is going to change. The coolest thing to me in
this herd are two Chianina x Sayaguesa cows. Bionade was introduced in my 2013
post already. She is 3 years old now. Her colour is very diluted, which is not
surprising since she is half Chianina which have dilution genes on at least two
loci (dun [semidominant], agouti [recessive]), perhaps more. The
horns are tiny, but I do not consider that dramatic considering the potential
she bears regarding size and body shape/proportions. She is rather tame, and I measured
her at about 155cm. The other Chianina x Sayaguesa cow (79 810) has a really
nice body shape: slender waist, hump and good proportions. In this respect she
is one of the best cows in my opinion. Bionade has a calf plus a 1,5 year old
daughter 01 816. She looks good, let us see how her horns are going to be. The father is Laokoon (Sayaguesa x (Heck x Chianina)), who was sold.
Breeding bull Linnet (Sayaguesa x mix)
Linnet's horns: good curvature, but should protrude longer
Bionade, Sayaguesa x Chianina. 155 cm tall at the shoulders.
79 810, another Sayaguesa x Chianina.
Bionade and 01 816
01 816, Bionade's daughter
Ludovica, an old Heck x Chianina
01 851, son of Linnet & Ludovica
Klostermersch-Nordseite
This herd
is the one with the highest Lidia portion, because (unless I am wrong), the
Lidia x Heck bull Loco (now dead) was used as a breeding bull for a few years.
Loco is the father of Latino, who also produced a few animals (by the way, my
suspicion I had in 2013 that Latino is the father of this bull at the right at Pöppelsche was
confirmed). He is the father of Limicola falcinellus, whose mother had Loco as
father as well. She also has a bit of Chianina in her ancestry. Luzerne is a cow
that could be mistaken for a “normal” Heck cow – she is indeed largely Heck,
but also Sayaguesa and Lidia. The herd has a number of nice young bulls. The
best one of those, 79 843 (I presume), a son of L. falcinellus, has large horns
and looks nice over all. But he will be removed because he is one of the
“nervous ones”. But there are other nice young bulls there as well that I am
unable to identify because the ear marks are not clear on my photos. There is a
half-Chianina cow (Linea) in the herd, which is another daughter of Lombriz and
half-blood sister of Larissa. She is, not surprisingly, the tallest one in the
herd, but not as tall as her sister. 92 579 is an interesting case because of
her colour with the dark mouth. It is a dilution that is found in Highland
pretty often, but also in Lidia and rarely appears in Heck cattle to (the most
obvious trait is the dark mouth). Because it is way more common in Lidia than
Heck cattle, I thought Lidia might be responsible for that colour at first. But
in Disselmersch, there is another cow with that colour that does not have Lidia
ancestry. Maybe Chianina carries the alleles for that colour, masked by the
dilution factors. The cow Lambada has very good horns speaking of curvature (they
could be longer and thicker) and is three quarters Heck and one quarter
Sayaguesa. The cow 79 845 is the daughter of Churro (pure Sayaguesa bull) and
Linea, so mostly Sayaguesa and Chianina.
One of the
highlights in the herd is Lamarck. He is eight years old now and the new
breeding bull at Klostermersch-Nordseite (was also used on Kl.-Südseite for a
short time) now, and I still think that he is the best-looking Taurus bull I
have seen so far. He is good in all respects – not perfect, but really nice. I
guess most of my readers will know, but Lamarck is the son of Luca and
Dona-Urraca, therefore Sayaguesa x (Heck x Chianina).
Another
highlight is the presence of a Wörth cow named Nadia. There had been no pure
Heck cattle in the Lippeaue for a few years (for good reason, of course), but I
always thought a cross between a large-horned Wörth cow and a good Taurus bull
would be interesting. Early in February, Walter Frisch sold his herd at Insel Wörth,
and the ABU decided to by a good cow. Although huge-horned Erni was not
available, they got a good one (at first I thought they would purchase Arizona,
but they choose Nadia, which has larger horns). The Wörth cow and Lamarck are
flirting around a lot, so we can expect the vision of a Taurus-Wörth cross
becoming reality next year. Of course it will depend on chance how this
combination will look like, but it is about the potential that is in it. If you
look at the photos, you can also see the prominent size difference.
Lambada, Limicola falc., and 79 843
Luzerne
Limicola falcinellus
Young bull, don't know which one
Linea, 79 843
92 579
79 845
Young bull, don't know which one.
Lamarck, Sayaguesa x (Chianina x Heck)
Nadia, a Heck cow from Insel Wörth
Lamarck and Nadia; note the size difference.
Disselmersch
This is the
herd that changed the most since 2013. Back then, the herd was composed of
animals that were mostly influenced by Heck and Sayaguesa only. The breeding
bull Larwin was slaughtered because he was not good: small head, long body with
short legs, long dewlap. The oldest cow there died and I was not able to find
other individuals of the old herd in the current stock list. The new herd is
composed of young individuals. The bull, 01 856, is not bad overall. I
especially like the shape of his head, but the horns are really small. The bull
is about one and a half years old, so they would continue to grow, but they
would still remain less then desirable. So it was decided that he is going to
be slaughtered and – if I remember correctly – replaced by the young bull from
Kleiberg. 01 856 is the son of Laokoon and Larissa. The best cow there is 42 650, a daughter of Lamarck and Lirgit. 79
842 is a daughter of Lamarck as well, and her mother was 42 634, a “true F2”
Sayaguesa x (Heck x Chianina) (now butchered, behaviour was undesirable). That
means she might be genetically more stable, but her aspect is not that
impressing to me. 01 852 is another one of the three dark-mouthed cows. Her
parents are Laokoon – Sayaguesa x (Heck x Chianina) and Lale – (Heck x
Sayaguesa) x (Heck x Chianina). So she rules out that Lidia is responsible for
that colour variant. The young greyish cow looks promising (don’t know her
combination EDIT: She is a fullblood sister of Larissa, therefore 62% Chianina) in regards to her proportions and body shape, but unfortunately
she might be infertile because she is twin with a male.
The bull 01 856 in the middle
79 842 (left) and 42 650 (right)
01 852. With its pink nose and the dark mouth, her colour reminds me of Highland and other breeds.
Well proportioned but maybe infertile.
By the way, here you can have a look at a video of the Disselmersch herd (not filmed by me):
I am very sad to read that getting an auroch - like breed is just a "side project": this must be the main causes of some crucial management decision, like select out the "nervous ones". Behavioral features like this should be carefully studied before taking a decision, they likely are needed for a self - sufficient free ranging life, and will be anyway positively selected ( but slowly ) in such conditions. One of the Rewilding Europe association goal, they claim, is to set free in their areas several herds of minimum 150 heads each one. Maybe joining forces all the project involved in breeding back could find the funds needed
She was pregnant when she arrived in the Lippeaue, so that's a pure Heck calf. If it is male, they will remove it in any case; if it is female, it may or may be kept if it is good or either removed.
The calf shouldn't be pure Heck since it has Watusi in it's linage, giving it the larger horns. I think it would be interesting to cross it with a Sayaguesa, or Chianina, to see if would increase their horn size.
If you didn't call all Heck cattle with that one Watussi cow in that ancestry a "pure Heck", large quantities of modern Heck cattle wouldn't be "pure Heck cattle". In fact, that one Watussi cow was not the only other breed that was crossed in after 1945, also Hungarian Grey were crossed in again several times. There is no reason not to call them "pure".
My point is should a bull be removed if it could have something valuable to contribute genetically to the Taurus breed (It's larger horns with better angle than Hungarian Greys) or be removed because meets some definition of being pure Heck. Anyway I thank you for your extremely interesting, well written and informative post.
They would not remove it just because it would be a Heck bull, but because using a Heck bull as a breeding bull (or on larger scale than just one cow), would counteract what has been achieved already, i.e. size, long snouts, long legs and so on.
I am very sad to read that getting an auroch - like breed is just a "side project": this must be the main causes of some crucial management decision, like select out the "nervous ones". Behavioral features like this should be carefully studied before taking a decision, they likely are needed for a self - sufficient free ranging life, and will be anyway positively selected ( but slowly ) in such conditions. One of the Rewilding Europe association goal, they claim, is to set free in their areas several herds of minimum 150 heads each one. Maybe joining forces all the project involved in breeding back could find the funds needed
ReplyDeleteIs that Nadia's calf in the photo with her. If it is, do you know what bull is the father?
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteShe was pregnant when she arrived in the Lippeaue, so that's a pure Heck calf. If it is male, they will remove it in any case; if it is female, it may or may be kept if it is good or either removed.
DeleteThe calf shouldn't be pure Heck since it has Watusi in it's linage, giving it the larger horns. I think it would be interesting to cross it with a Sayaguesa, or Chianina, to see if would increase their horn size.
DeleteIf you didn't call all Heck cattle with that one Watussi cow in that ancestry a "pure Heck", large quantities of modern Heck cattle wouldn't be "pure Heck cattle". In fact, that one Watussi cow was not the only other breed that was crossed in after 1945, also Hungarian Grey were crossed in again several times. There is no reason not to call them "pure".
DeleteMy point is should a bull be removed if it could have something valuable to contribute genetically to the Taurus breed (It's larger horns with better angle than Hungarian Greys) or be removed because meets some definition of being pure Heck.
DeleteAnyway I thank you for your extremely interesting, well written and informative post.
They would not remove it just because it would be a Heck bull, but because using a Heck bull as a breeding bull (or on larger scale than just one cow), would counteract what has been achieved already, i.e. size, long snouts, long legs and so on.
Delete